What a Potential Fight With Islam Makhachev Means for Justin Gaethje

A showdown between Justin Gaethje and Islam Makhachev has fight fans buzzing. For Gaethje, it’s not just another high-profile bout—it’s a shot at legacy-defining glory. But standing in his way is Makhachev, a dominant force whose reign has solidified him as one of the greatest lightweights in MMA history.

At UFC 311, Makhachev etched his name into the record books, setting the mark for most UFC Lightweight Championship wins and defenses. That achievement has fueled debates about his place in the sport’s hierarchy, with many now considering him the greatest lightweight of all time.

Since then, speculation over his next opponent has been rampant. Arman Tsarukyan and Charles Oliveira have been floated as possible challengers, but Makhachev himself has shown interest in facing Gaethje—provided Gaethje gets past Dan Hooker at UFC 313.

A native of Arizona, Gaethje is widely regarded as one of the most electrifying lightweights in MMA. His relentless aggression and devastating striking have made him a fan favorite, yet one key accomplishment has eluded him: a UFC championship.

While his striking power is his calling card, Gaethje’s grappling is often overlooked. That skill set could prove invaluable against Makhachev, whose suffocating Sambo-based grappling has neutralized some of the division’s best fighters. Gaethje’s ability to keep the fight standing and force a striking battle may be his best path to victory.

Makhachev’s style is built on relentless pressure, chain wrestling, and positional dominance. His ability to control opponents on the ground has made him nearly unstoppable. If he can impose that game on Gaethje, it could be a long night for the former interim champion.

The key factors in this potential matchup revolve around Gaethje’s takedown defense and striking power. If he can stay upright, his leg kicks and knockout ability could disrupt Makhachev’s rhythm. However, Gaethje’s history of engaging in chaotic brawls could be a double-edged sword—against an opponent as disciplined as Makhachev, patience and calculated aggression will be crucial.

For Gaethje, a win would be transformative. It would make him the UFC Lightweight Champion and elevate him into the all-time great conversation. At 36 years old, this may be his best—and last—chance at gold. Conversely, a loss would be a significant setback, potentially closing the championship window for good.

On the other side, a victory over Gaethje would only bolster Makhachev’s already legendary résumé. Defeating one of the division’s most dangerous strikers would further solidify his dominance and quiet any remaining skeptics.

Before this dream matchup can materialize, Gaethje must first take care of business against Dan Hooker at UFC 313. Hooker, a durable and well-rounded veteran, presents a formidable test. A convincing win would leave no doubt that Gaethje is next in line for a shot at Makhachev’s throne.

The prospect of Gaethje vs. Makhachev is more than just an exciting fight—it’s a clash of styles, legacies, and championship stakes. A Gaethje victory would upend the lightweight division, while a Makhachev win would further cement his stranglehold at the top.

In the end, this isn’t just about another fight. It’s about defining careers. Gaethje has one final shot at immortality, while Makhachev looks to continue his reign as the lightweight GOAT. If this bout comes to fruition, it has all the makings of an all-time classic.